We have tested the performance of one ad with the same copy, text, title, and call to action with Facebook Dynamic Creative. Check out the results!
In order to improve our business, like every company on the market these days, we decided to use Facebook ads to find and attract new clients. To be honest, firstly we started to work on increasing our SEO, but for that, we need “traffic”, and since we already had a Facebook page with more than 1K likes this was a good starting point for our plan to increase traffic.
As we gained a lot of experience with Facebook ads while we were working for our clients, we wanted to use this knowledge for our agency.
When you start to work on your campaign, there is a lot of details on which you need to pay attention, but in our case study, we want to test the performance of one ad with the same copy (description), text, title and call to action. We will test the amount of content on an image which means that we have one photo in three variants. On the first image, we didn’t add any text to the image, on the second one we added one sentence, and on the last one, we added text on more than 20% of the image.
I mention this 20% because that is a popular Facebook 20% text rule. Until 2016 Facebook advertisers were allowed to cover only 20% of an image with text, so if your text covered more than 20% of an image your ad wouldn’t run because Facebook would reject it. With the new Facebook 20% text rule, advertisers have more freedom (I will come back to this later in the article) with text on images, and your image gets text ratings from Facebook. You can check image ratings on this link.
- Image Text: OK
Your ad will run normally.
- Image Text: Low
Your ad’s reach may be slightly lower.
- Image Text: Medium
Your ad’s reach may be much lower.
- Image Text: High
Your ad may not run.
Two of three photos in our example have been rated as OK, but stay with us till the end of the article and check the results of performing ads and get familiar with a Facebook algorithm of showing ads.
The main question in your mind should be next: Which version of the image would perform the best in the campaign? As I am a designer, in my soul, I would bet that the third image would perform the best but through this article, you will find out that I am completely wrong.
We all have some budget for advertising, and in the end, you have to get some results like conversions or emails, etc. In other words, your costs need to have results. As I said, we created three variants of an image and simply tested them with Facebook Dynamic Creative. Here is a total guide to what we have done and in the end, we will show you results.
With Facebook Dynamic Creative you can test multiple variants of ads. You can change:
Images or Videos
Call To Action Button
Supported objectives in which you can currently use Facebook Dynamic Creative are brand awareness, reach, traffic, app installs, video views, lead generation, and conversions.
Advice: Double check if the objective from your campaign is one of the listed above (brand awareness, reach, traffic, etc), otherwise you won’t be able to start working with Dynamic Creative.
You can test up to 30 variables to see which performs the best, so you can combine the following:
Text: 5 options max
Images/Videos: 10 images, video or slideshow options max
Headlines: 5 options max
Link descriptions: 5 options max
Call To Action (CTA) buttons: 5 options max
If your budget is limited (as in most cases) we suggest you test a smaller number of combinations so you don’t get lost.
Setting up Dynamic Creative
Let’s start with the setting up Dynamic Creative in your campaign. In the Facebook Ads Manager select the campaign in which you want to work.
Setting up Ad in Facebook Dynamic Creative – Step 1
After you put a ✓ here, click on tab Ad Sets and on the green button Create.
Setting up Ad in Facebook Dynamic Creative – Step 2
On your screen should appear the display shown below and here you will choose ON to Dynamic Creative.
Setting up Ad in Facebook Dynamic Creative – Step 3
I won’t get into details on how to target your audience, but regarding Placements of your ad I recommend you click on Edit Placements and personally choose where do you want to show your ad. You can check the list of supported placements in Dynamic Creative on the link. In our case, we show an ad in Facebook Feeds and in the Right Column.
After setting up the budget and scheduling the rest of “details” of Ad Set, you are ready to move further so click on the Continue and now you should be in the Ad.
If you are running more than one Facebook Page before you start, make sure you are creating an ad for the right page or choose it by clicking on it in the drop-down menu.
Choose Single Image and below you will upload variants of images that you want to test. Here we added our three photos. Also, below this you can write your text (up to five options), add a link, then headline (up to five options) which you want to test, choose a call to action, etc.
You can add only one link for all combinations of your ad.
I recommend you to set up Facebook Pixel here, as all results will then be measured in pixel.
Setting up Ad in Facebook Dynamic Creative – Step 4
Now it is time to preview all variants of the ad. Scroll down and in the right corner click View More Variations.
Setting up Ad in Facebook Dynamic Creative – Step 5
Then click on the drop-down menu and check all possible combinations of the ad. In our case, we can preview ad with three different images, but copy, headline, and call to action are the same.
Preview of Ads in Facebook Dynamic Creative – Step 6
How to Measure the Result?
After you set up your ad using dynamic creative, you need to know which ad variant is performing the best.
To check the results you need to be in Ads Manager, select the campaign with ✓ and then select the Ad set again with ✓ in front of it.
In the right corner you have a Breakdown drop-down menu where you click on By Dynamic Creative Asset, and then decide by which metrics you want to filter data. We click on the image as we had three variants of an image.
Results in Facebook Dynamic Creative – Step 7
Results in Facebook Dynamic Creative – Step 8
As Facebook Dynamic Creative Ads are relatively new on the market, it could happen that you sometimes don’t have this option in Breakdown. In that case, try to close Ad Manager and start it up again (believe it or not this worked in our case).
Results in Facebook Dynamic Creative – Step 9
All things considered, we can see that as you make the text in your images longer, Facebook will make your life harder. Even though there has been an update of 20% text rule, ads with long text on an image are not performing well. Our image that has more than 20% of it covered with text is faceads3, and it is performing the worst of all three tested images. Reach (2,299), impressions (5,296) and clicks are bad, but you can see that the cost is the lowest. The average cost to reach 1,000 people is $0.12.
The image with no text at all is named faceads and it is on some average, we have reached 4,672 people and 22,455 impressions. The average cost to reach 1,000 people is $0.24 and we have some clicks on this image.
I was saving the best for the end. The image with one sentence of text is named facead2 and the results are amazing. We have 102,017 impressions and reach of 9,371 people, though clicks are not promising. In comparison to the results of the other two photos, you see that this is our bingo combination. The average cost to reach 1,000 people is $0.65 and cost per result is the most expensive, but no matter the cost this is our winning choice. Just take a look one more time at the result from this image, and keep in mind that all images had the same precondition, but only this one had great achievement.
What You Should Do?
Test it. Yes, you need time to test and find the best option, but as you can see Facebook will try to show you the solution which should work for your business. In our example, you can see that the performance of the image with little text is having a significant impression and reach. We also need to work on CTR as results are not perfect, but this is what we have for now. Did you try working with Facebook Dynamic Creative? Either you have your own idea and you want to consult with our experts or you just want to share your opinion, feel free to Contact Us